Keynote · CSL Workshop 2026 · TU München · 5 October 2026 · Nils Boeffel
Old challenges and new opportunities
Change the (research) operating system
AI is getting cheaper and more capable faster than organizations, laws and institutions can change. The keynote follows that gap through four levels, the world, society, the organization and the workshop itself, and asks at each one who wins, and how. For research software the answer starts with a shift in cost. The upkeep that was never affordable, such as tests and documentation, has become cheap with AI, while judging whether a result is right has not. Code is therefore worth less as something to guard, data and validated cases are worth more, and no university group, vendor or engineering team holds everything it needs.
Links
- The workshop: Computational Simulation Lab Workshop 2026, TUM Institute for Advanced Study, Garching, 5 to 7 October 2026.
- Questions about the talk: Nils Boeffel on LinkedIn.
Summary
A pond, and a question
The lily pads on a pond double every day, and on day 83 the pond is completely covered. On which day is it half covered? It is half covered on day 82, one day before it is full, and a week earlier, with less than 1% covered, it still looks empty. Most people know the answer and have to think about it anyway, because exponential growth is logical without being intuitive.
AI poses the same problem at scale. Its capability compounds, while everything that has to absorb it moves at the speed of building sites and court rulings. The keynote asks who wins, and how, at four levels that run from the world down to the workshop itself.
World: capability compounds, the brakes add delays
Epoch AI’s chart of the “plunging price of thought” shows AI getting about 13 times cheaper every year between 2021 and 2026. The price of computing took roughly 35 years to fall that far.
The keynote’s reading is that what drives AI forward feeds on itself. Models carry a growing share of the work of building the next models, most users don’t have to install anything new, and no lab or country will slow down on its own. What holds it back can only be built one piece at a time. A chip fab takes three to five years to set up and a power plant with its grid connection five to ten. Trust grows with each standard and each court ruling, and organizations change at human speed.
So the exponential wins, and the linear brakes decide when and where.
Society: who gets ahead when thinking gets cheap?
The keynote offers three trends here and no answers. In the US, the share of children who earn more than their parents fell from 92% for those born in 1940 to 50% for those born in 1984 (Chetty et al.). Discount the post-war boom that carried the earliest of those cohorts, and the fall from 1960 on is slower but still there, from 62% to 50%. Labor’s share of income has shrunk in most countries. Since the 1990s the middle tier of jobs has thinned out while high-end professional work grew, and AI now reaches that top tier too.
Cheap thinking also works in the other direction, and three of its effects may keep the way up open.
- Cheaper to start. One person with AI can do what once needed a company, at least in office work.
- Cheaper expertise. Education, legal advice and medical advice were costly steps on the way up, and AI is making them cheap.
- New kinds of work. About 60% of the jobs of 2018 didn’t exist in 1940 (Autor et al.), and nobody can say yet what the new ones will be.
None of this fixes the timing, because laws and schools take decades to change while AI moves in quarters. For the individual, the keynote’s advice is to “educate yourself up”, because climbing through work alone is getting harder while knowledge and ability still count.
Organization: adoption is faster, adaptation is slower
Planning is where the pace shows first. Ten-year strategic plans are giving way to much shorter ones, because nobody knows what two years from now looks like, and the leader’s job shifts with them, from planning to guidance. What people need from the top in a world like this is vision, understanding, clarity and agility, not a plan that will be wrong by the time it is printed.
Every organization has two tasks. The first is to adopt the technology. That can go quickly when four forces work together, a model the keynote takes from Nicolai Tangen’s account of AI adoption at Norges Bank Investment Management. Leadership has to want it, and people need the tools and the data access. Training has to reach across teams, and someone has to translate between the business and IT so that results end up in daily work.
Adapting the organization is the second task, and the harder one. Argyris and Schön called it double-loop learning. The single loop asks how to do the work, and AI has made that nearly free, because techniques can be tried and thrown away in hours. The double loop asks why, and questioning the assumptions behind the work costs what it always did, because those assumptions are the real operating system of an organization. What makes it expensive is admitting that an assumption was wrong.
The workshop: what got cheap, and what to trade
The workshop brought together about 80 people who develop and use simulation software, from universities, software vendors and industry. Their old problems are familiar well beyond research. Code outlives its authors, knowledge leaves with the PhD student who wrote it, a proof of concept never becomes a product, and open science collides with industrial IP.
Much of this could be fixed by tests, build pipelines, documentation and refactoring, work that was never affordable and has just become cheap. Nils Boeffel built a production system with AI for a small metal manufacturer in about five months, with 30 to 40% of the effort going into tests and pipelines, because AI output keeps diverging unless it is given a point to converge to. Software that can be rebuilt this quickly is worth less as IP than it used to be. Data and validated real cases are worth more.
That system also replaced an application one person had maintained for about 15 years, and if its builder left tomorrow, someone with IT and AI skills could take it over in about two days by asking the repository how it works and why it was built that way. Knowledge can live in the code, the documentation and the network rather than in one head, provided they are structured for that on purpose.
That changes what the four groups at the workshop (professors, PhD students, software vendors and industrial users) can offer each other, and the links between them are the slow part today. Methods take years to reach industry, requirements are rarely passed back, and real cases are rarely shared. The keynote gave the working groups four questions to take along.
- What must you keep? The one thing no proposal may cost you.
- What got cheap? Code and tools are cheaper to rebuild, so what do you really give up by sharing them?
- What do you lack? Someone who checks your AI-assisted work, your next senior, continuity beyond one person, real cases, a faster path for methods.
- Who here has it? Whoever has what you lack and needs what you have is your trade.
A good trade costs nobody what they must keep and gives each side something it could not get alone.
One problem stays open. Writing was junior work and checking is senior work, so if AI does the writing, fewer juniors learn to check, and nobody knows where the seniors of ten years from now will come from. Simulation engineers already own the discipline that helps, because a simulation isn’t trusted until it is verified and validated, and AI-assisted work deserves the same treatment.
Who wins, and how?
The question from the start has a different answer at each level.
- World: the exponential, while the linear brakes decide when and where.
- Society: those who “educate themselves up”.
- Organization: those who adapt as fast as they adopt.
- The workshop: those who ask the critical questions and change how they work together.
The closing slide reads “1+1=3, for extremely large values of 1”. The keynote’s point is that a workshop like this one is a chance for the sum to be greater than its parts, at a time when more can be achieved in a short time than ever before.